The Ultimate Fishing Reel Guide 2025 – Reel Types, Sizes & My Top Picks
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases — no cost to you. That’s how we keep this site running. Read more ›
Let me say it straight — the fishing reel is the most important part of your setup. You can have the best rod in the world, the most expensive line, or the deadliest lure, but if your reel fails you, none of that matters. I’ve learned that the hard way. I’ve had reels jam mid-fight, drags lock up during the most critical moments, and handles snap in cold weather. That’s when it hit me — you don’t just fish with a reel, you rely on a fishing reel to deliver performance every time.
A high-quality fishing reel isn’t about luxury — it’s about control, precision, and trust. The right reel makes every cast smoother, every retrieve more efficient, and every fight more manageable. The wrong reel will make you hate fishing, no matter how passionate you are. And with the number of options out there — hundreds of fishing reels from dozens of brands — it’s no wonder most beginners (and even a lot of experienced anglers) get confused when choosing the best fishing reel for their style.
That’s why I decided to break it down. If you’re unsure what kind of fishing reel you need or why one is better than another, this guide will save you hours of research — and probably a few headaches too. Let’s go over the main types of fishing reels, what they’re for, and when to use each one so you can confidently choose the best fishing reel for your next trip.
The Main Types of Fishing Reels Explained
1. Spinning Reels (Open-Faced)
Spinning reels are by far the most popular and versatile type of reel…
If you’re just starting out or you want a reliable all-around reel…
2. Baitcasting Reels (For Power and Precision)
Baitcasters are made for more experienced anglers…
However, when used right, baitcasters are unbeatable…
3. Spincast Reels (Beginner-Friendly but Limited)
Spincast reels are the simplest type — they’re the ones with a closed front…
But they have downsides. Limited line capacity…
4. Saltwater and Surf Fishing Reels
Saltwater reels — both spinning and baitcasting — are built to resist corrosion…
Surf fishing reels are a subcategory of saltwater reels…
Choosing the Right Reel for Your Style of Fishing
The type of reel you should use depends on what you’re targeting…
- Targeting bass in open water? A spinning reel with 10–20 lb braid is a killer setup.
- Fishing frogs in heavy grass? You need a baitcaster with strong drag and fast retrieval.
- Taking a kid fishing for bluegill? Grab a spincast combo and a can of worms.
- Heading to the coast? Go with a saltwater spinning reel rated for corrosion resistance.
It’s all about matching your reel to your technique…
Understanding Reel Sizes – What Do 1000, 2500, or 5000 Actually Mean?
One of the most common questions I get is about reel sizes…
Here’s a quick breakdown to make it easier:
- 1000–2000: Ultra-light reels for trout, panfish…
- 2500–3000: All-purpose spinning reels for bass…
- 4000–5000: Heavier-duty reels for pike, catfish…
- 6000 and up: Big-game reels. Ideal for saltwater monsters…
Choosing the right reel size depends on what you’re fishing for…
The bottom line: match the reel size to your target species and fishing technique…
These Are the Reels I Trust
Over the years, I’ve tested countless reels. Some were disappointments…
Shimano Vanford – My Ultimate All-Around Spinning Reel
I’ve used a lot of spinning reels over the years, but the Shimano Vanford stands in a class of its own. When I first picked it up, I was struck by how light it felt. It almost seemed too light to be powerful — but that assumption disappeared the first time I hooked into a solid bass and realized this reel was built like a high-end machine. Smooth drag, instant anti-reverse, tight tolerances — it gave me total control, and I never looked back.
The Vanford is more than just a reel I like — it’s one I trust. I’ve used it in countless situations: finesse drop shotting, light jigging, long casts with swimbaits — and every time it performed flawlessly. It’s become my go-to reel for freshwater spinning, and I honestly recommend it to anyone who wants one reel that can do it all.
Key Features That Matter
- Weight: Extremely light carbon CI4+ body — ideal for long sessions without fatigue.
- Drag System: Smooth and consistent with no jerkiness — excellent for finesse setups.
- Gear Ratio: Fast enough for quick pickups, especially useful with soft plastics.
- Micromodule II + SilentDrive: It feels insanely smooth and tight — zero play in the handle.
- Water Resistance: CoreProtect system keeps the internals safe even in light saltwater conditions.
The engineering behind this reel shows. Shimano packed it with high-end technology without going overboard or making it fragile. It feels solid but agile — like a lightweight fighter that hits above its weight class.
Best Use Cases
I mainly use the Vanford for bass fishing, but it’s equally deadly on trout, perch, and even small inshore saltwater species. It shines with finesse techniques — things like Ned rigs, drop shots, weightless plastics, and small swimbaits. The sensitivity you get from this reel, paired with a good rod, is unmatched. You feel everything. And with its lightweight build, I can fish 6–8 hours without my wrist screaming at me.
- Light to medium bass fishing setups
- Trout and finesse fishing in rivers and streams
- Inshore fishing for redfish or flounder with lighter tackle
- Long casting with smaller lures
Final Verdict
The Shimano Vanford is my “if I could only have one reel” choice. It’s smooth, precise, and reliable. It fits almost any technique short of power fishing in the jungle. It looks good, feels even better, and performs flawlessly cast after cast. Whether you’re a beginner looking for one great spinning reel or a tournament angler needing finesse performance — this one delivers.
Daiwa BG MQ – Pure Power, Unmatched Smoothness
When I picked up the Daiwa BG MQ for the first time, I knew I was dealing with a reel designed for serious fishing. The build quality is immediately noticeable – solid, yet refined. This is the kind of spinning reel that feels like it could take on a monster fish and still keep going without flinching.
Why I Recommend the Daiwa BG MQ
What sets the Daiwa BG MQ apart is the monocoque (MQ) body. It gives the reel a more compact form without sacrificing power. It’s incredibly rigid and eliminates flex under heavy pressure – meaning, when that 10-pounder hits, your reel holds up like a tank.
Drag performance is ultra-smooth thanks to Daiwa’s ATD (Automatic Tournament Drag) system. No jerky starts or sudden slips — just consistent pressure from the hookset to the boat.
Key Features
- Monocoque aluminum body for unmatched strength
- Waterproof drag system with high max drag
- Oversized gear for superior torque
- Solid screw-in handle – no wobble, full control
- Air Rotor design reduces weight while improving balance
Perfect For
The Daiwa BG MQ is perfect for inshore saltwater fishing, targeting stronger species like redfish, snook, striped bass, or even light offshore jigging. But I’ve also used it in freshwater, especially when going after aggressive pike and catfish.
It handles braid and fluorocarbon with ease, casts far, retrieves smoothly, and never backs down. It’s the reel I trust when conditions are tough and stakes are high.
Final Verdict
If you’re looking for a tough, smooth, and reliable spinning reel that can handle just about anything, the Daiwa BG MQ is my no-brainer recommendation. It looks good, feels incredible, and performs like a beast.
Pflueger President XT – The Best Budget Reel That Doesn’t Feel Cheap
I’ve used more expensive reels, and I’ve used cheaper ones — but the Pflueger President XT is that rare find that hits the sweet spot. It’s affordable, smooth, durable, and surprisingly fun to use. When I first tried it, I didn’t expect much. For under $100, you usually get a reel that feels like a toy. But the President XT felt solid, confident, and surprisingly refined.
Over the past few years, I’ve put this reel through everything — bass fishing, trout trips, even some light saltwater action. It held up. I still grab it when I want a reliable setup that I don’t have to worry about. And every time, I think, “Damn… this thing still performs.”
Key Features That Deliver More Than Expected
- 10-Bearing System: Smooth retrieval, even under load. Honestly feels like reels twice its price.
- Aluminum Body + Carbon Handle: Lightweight but not cheap-feeling. Nice balance.
- Sealed Drag: Holds up well in wet conditions. Surprisingly strong for a sub-$100 reel.
- Braid-Ready Spool: You can tie braid straight to it — no backing needed.
- Fast Gear Ratio: Picks up line quickly — ideal for drop shot and light jig work.
Who This Reel Is Perfect For
This is the reel I recommend to people who are just getting into fishing, or to anyone who wants a reliable backup setup that doesn’t break the bank. It’s not the flashiest reel. It doesn’t come with cutting-edge tech or carbon everything. But what it does, it does extremely well.
- Light and medium bass fishing (Texas rig, drop shot, finesse plastics)
- Trout and panfish fishing in rivers, creeks, and lakes
- Budget inshore fishing — redfish, snook, small jacks
- Anglers who want real value without compromise
Final Verdict
The Pflueger President XT delivers smooth drag, solid construction, and reliable performance at a price point that’s hard to beat. It’s one of the few budget reels I truly enjoy using — a dependable workhorse I recommend with confidence.
Choose Smart, Fish Bold
The fishing reel you choose isn’t just another piece of gear — it’s the connection between you and the water. Whether you’re chasing your personal best or just out for a relaxing day on the lake, the right fishing reel makes every cast smoother, every retrieve more confident, and every fight more enjoyable. It’s not about price — it’s about performance, durability, and how well the reel fits your fishing style.
These three fishing reels have earned my trust, and I’d buy them again in a heartbeat. I’ve tested dozens — some failed, some were average, and a few stood out. The ones above? They stood out. If you’re building your setup from scratch or upgrading a worn-out fishing reel, these are safe bets that deliver. Each one is balanced, efficient, and ready to perform when it matters most.
No matter where you fish — lakes, rivers, or coastal waters — having the right fishing reel in your hand means you’re already ahead of the game. It boosts your confidence, improves your accuracy, and lets you focus on what matters: the strike, the fight, and the satisfaction of landing that perfect catch.
If this guide helped you pick your next fishing reel, check out more of my fishing gear reviews, tutorials, and field-tested recommendations. And if you’ve got a favorite reel that never let you down, share it with me — I’m always on the lookout for the next great find.
